Newsletter missing events

We used to have our newsletter come out once a week and then suddenly it stopped. I checked and it was turned off so I turned it back on again. However, ever since then it no longer includes our upcoming events in it even though the majority of our events show as “Everyone” being invited.

Here is what our newsletter now looks like:


Here is what our typical calendar event looks like for permissions:

And here is what our newsletter settings are set to:

How do we get it so our events are returned to the newsletter?